Puckett's Mill Elementary School received the Silver Award for Highest Performing Schools in 2018 in the state of Georgia, exhibiting high academic performance by earning a three-year average CCRPI Achievement Score in at least the 95th percentile.

Puckett's Mill Elementary School received the Bronze Award for Highest Performing Schools in 2017 in the state of Georgia, exhibiting high academic performance by earning a three-year average CCRPI Achievement Score in at least the 93rd percentile.